Ancient Treatment For Depression And Melancholia

depress1

What did the ancients think about depression, and how to cure it?  We will look at the views of Celsus, who wrote the most complete medical guide that has survived from Roman times (excluding the writings of Galen).

We know almost nothing about the life of Aulus Cornelius Celsus.  Even the dates of his birth and death are uncertain; most estimates place them between 25 B.C. and 50 A.D.  He is important to history for the medical treatise he left behind.  This book, called De Medicina, was originally part of a larger encyclopedia that covered a vast number of topics.  For me it is a fascinating window into how people of his era thought about the body and its ailments.

His recommendations for the treatment of depression, melancholia, and insanity are still of value.  The human body has not changed since his day, even though our environment and technology have.  My hope is that someone reading this article may find these suggestions to be of some use.  It actually does happen.  I have read that some of Celsus’s recommendations on the amputation of limbs were actually used in the First World War.

The points below appear in book III, chapter 18 of De Medicina.

1.  Sufferers of melancholia respond differently to light or dark rooms.  Some prefer to be kept in dark rooms; others prefer well-lit spaces.  It all depends on the patient, and the care-giver should be sensitive to his needs.  As he says, Neutrum autem perpetuum est:  alium enim lux, alium tenebrae magis turbant.  And this means, “Neither way is always right:  light upsets some, and darkness upsets another.”

2.  The head can be shaved, and then rubbed with water infused with “vervains” (verbenae).  Rose oil can also be poured over the head and into the nostrils.  The patient can also inhale rue mixed with vinegar.  Another remedy is saffron ointment with “orris” rubbed on the head (crocinum unguentum cum irino in caput additum).

Other medicaments also provide some relief for the sufferer.  Celsus advises that the juice of the herbs “bitter-sweet” (solanum) and “pellitory” (muralis) can be rubbed on a shaved head to alleviate delusions and sadness.

Also good for “composing the mind” are preparations of “decoction of poppy” or “hyoscyamus” (papaver aut hyoscyamos) mixed with water.  Some physicians recommend smearing the forehead with cardamomum balsam or sycamine tears (amomum vel sycamini lacrmam fronti inducunt).

However, not all physicians agree with these herbal remedies, Celsus says.  Asclepiades, a Greek doctor whose writings Celsus draws on for reference, says that herbal remedies for melancholia are of no use in the long term.  Instead, he recommended that the patient that he should for a day abstain from food, drink, and sleep.  And in the evenings, he should be rubbed gently about the body.  This kind of massaging was very effective; but too much rubbing can produce lethargy.

3.  Rubbing of the body and even immersions in water can work in some cases; but here again, we must realize that depression is very specific to each sufferer.

4.  If people are suffering from deep anxieties, you should try to relieve their fears by explaining how the fears are baseless.  Random laughter should be stopped by stern counsel and even threats.  For some depressed people, music, cymbals, and certain noises also work well.  Story-telling and games are great remedies for depression.

5.  It is often better to agree with the patient than to try to contradict or correct him.  In this way, the mind can be gradually moved from the irrational to the rational.

6.  It is also good to revive the patient’s interests.  You can read to him or play games with them.  The intention here is to try to divert them from the fears that torment their minds.  Try to get the patient to recite things he can remember.  The mind has to be made to “let go” of one thing and focus on something else.

7.  Sleep can be induced by the sound of gently falling water, or by the suspended feeling of being in a hammock.

8.  Sometimes purgatives work.  The patient can be given hellebore and then be induced to vomit.

9.  Madness is generally less serious when the insane person is laughing, than when he is overly grave and somber.

10.  The most controversial part of Celsus’s recommendations involve the administration of “tortures.”  He advises that the insane person can sometimes be treated by starvation, physical restraints, and “flogging.” The idea here was to shock the insane person’s body and mind and force him to take new mental directions.  Celsus says, “It is good to be suddenly terrified and completely scared; so is anything that powerfully excites the mind.”  When the mind is suddenly “snapped out” of one state, new possibilities open up.  Terror, in other words, works well.

11.  Depressed or insane people should also be made to exercise vigorously.  This also causes the spirit to become animated.

All in all, these remedies are actually not that bad.  Of course pharmaceutical science since Celsus’s day has advanced.  But we must remember that in his era, the only medicines that were available were the ones that could be found naturally in plants, or extracted from animals or minerals.

cave1

But if we look at these suggestions closely, we find them to be very shrewd ways to deal with depression. I wonder if any modern psychologist could come up with anything much better.  Celsus tells us to distract or divert the mind; to “shock” our systems with new stimuli; and to seek out nurturing environments.  I am a big believer in the “system shock” theory as a way to overcome depression.  You have to force your body and mind to “snap out” of its chemical patterns.

Although his advice on “tortures” may lend itself to abuse, there is at least a theory behind it.  By administering the body sudden and violent stimuli, the mind may be diverted from its depressive state.

Every now and then, all of us need a good jolt to get us moving, and to keep us moving.

 

Learn more about controlling your thinking and conduct in On Duties.  

 

8 thoughts on “Ancient Treatment For Depression And Melancholia

  1. These are some interesting methods to tackle depression. The entry on agreeing with the patient in order to move the mind from irrationality to rationality is something I’ve used on other people before. I found it to be a great temporary means of reversing depression, but didn’t work long term. Shock and torture therapy also seem like they would work.

    His idea on feeding the patient hellebore and inducing cleansing vomiting I think is rooted in the old philosophy/body system of humours. So getting the patient to purge himself of ill humours seems to be his aim there.

    In terms of strange methods to cure depression that do not involve pills or medicine, one I came across recently is sleep deprivation. Turns out getting someone to miss a night of sleep instantly alleviates his depression. Though sleeping again undoes it unless certain protocols are followed. Bright light therapy is another one. Have you come across anything pertaining to sleep deprivation in ancient writings?

    Liked by 1 person

      • Fascinating that they knew about it back then. I wonder just how muvh knowledge about the ailments and cures for the human condition have been lost to time, knowledge that we are only recently rediscovering, or ignoring and creating drugs.

        I think that bit about the “one day” refers to sleeping undoing the cure. One protocol I came across by a guy called Rogue Health and Fitness is to skip a night’s sleep, then go to bed at 5pm and sleep 7 hours. Wake up, and then only go to bed at 6pm, sleep 7 hours. Continue this bedtime advancement until sleeping time is 10 or 11pm. Apparently this doesn’t undo it.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. “6. It is also good to revive the patient’s interests. You can read to him or play games with them. The intention here is to try to divert them from the fears that torment their minds. Try to get the patient to recite things he can remember. The mind has to be made to “let go” of one thing and focus on something else.”

    I’ve found reading to be highly therapeutic, whether it is fiction or nonfiction. Even when I was reading Thucydides’ book on the Peloponnesian War, I was relaxed by the leisurely exercise. I can hardly think of a time when I was reading a book and became stressed.

    Books are the ultimate escape. Maybe it’s just me, but I find particularly with much older books the escape is even greater. Right now I’m reading City of God – a book written over 1,000 years ago. It’s hard to read it and not be transported back to the time period when it was written.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Yes, “Civitas Dei” is a huge work, and I’ve only read parts of it.
      It’s interesting that the depression cures described here all revolve around forcing the mind and body to “refocus” on different stimuli.

      Like

  3. So in essence, if you are depressed start moving and don’t keep staring at the floor wishing for it to go away. Use herbals to supplement your methods because modern medicine like Prozac is going to make things worse.

    One thing I would add is than when an intense feeling arises, say you feel a knot in your stomach, stay with it and start breathing deeply and as quick as possible and slow down eventually. Don’t try to ‘drown’ emotions with any substances like alcohol or any activities such as playing video games and watching movies.

    It’s better to confront negative emotions than ignoring them.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s