Sunday Movie Roundup (11/13/2016)


I didn’t post any reviews last week because I didn’t have any time to watch movies.  I did have some time this week.  Here are the results.

Uncle John (2015)

Director:  Steven Piet

I’m glad John Ashton is still making movies.  He’s one of those great character actors of the 1980s whose roles were not exactly huge, yet made an impression on the viewer.  You’ve seen him in Beverly Hills Cop (1984) and Midnight Run (1988).  He seemed to drop off the radar screen in the 1990s and 2000s, and I had thought he was retired from the grind.  To me, he’ll always be the rogue bounty hunter Marvin Dorffler from Midnight Run.  It’s one of my favorite films; I heard recently that he and Robert DeNiro were making a sequel.  If this is true, it will be a reunion that I’ll be first in line to see.

Despite my warmth towards Ashton, I can’t overlook the flaws in this mixed-bag of a film.  The plot:  an elderly farmer (John) in a small town kills a guy (named Dutch) everyone hates, then disposes of the body.  The dead man’s brother has his suspicions, and these only grow stronger with time.  In a separate sub-plot, John’s young nephew Ben romances a new co-worker.  He then pays his uncle a visit with his new girlfriend.

On the good side, Uncle John has a calm, reflective atmosphere that makes it watchable and moderately entertaining.  But the problem is that the film is just too bifurcated:  the director never really manages to tie the two unrelated plotlines together.  Worse still, the motivations behind John’s homicidal behavior are never explained, even indirectly.  Maybe director Steven Piet gave himself too much of a task in trying to mix two stories that just don’t go together.  Uncle John is decent enough, and I suppose worth watching, but it simply tries to explore philosophical territory that it has no business trespassing on.


The Measure Of A Man (2016) (Original Title:  La Loi Du Marché)

Director:   Stéphane Brizé

Better things are found in this understated little gem of French social commentary.  I love finding these types of films:  understated, serious, compelling, and containing a serious comment about human relations.

The plot:  an unemployed, older factory worker goes through the paces of trying to find new employment.  Everywhere he turns, he finds hypocrisy, double-talk, and mind-games.  When he does find employment, it is as a security guard catching shoplifters in one of those faceless megastores that dot the modern landscape.  The place is a soulless wasteland, seething under the surface with crushed dreams and broken lives.  As he talks to the shoplifters he apprehends, he begins to doubt the moral rectitude of some of the things he is asked to do.

This brilliant success of a film owes much to the superb acting of Vincent Lindon, who won an award at Cannes for his performance.  We see right away that, even though Lindon’s character is down on his luck, he is not a broken man.  This is a man of substance, a man of character.  His face is proud, his countenance quietly dignified, and his outlook on life redeeming.

Unlike what we would find in an American film, the director does not beat us over the head to prove his points.  He establishes the protagonist’s moral rectitude with little scenes.  In one, Lindon refuses to take part in a class-action lawsuit against a former employer, mindful of the toll that such a course would take on his mental health.  “At some point you need to draw a line in the sand, and move on,” he says.

Even the prospect of money, he tells his friends, is not worth it.  So right away we know that we are dealing with a grounded, morally-centered man.  This is further reinforced when we find that his son is handicapped, and that he faithfully supports him and his wife.  The marriage is a happy, well-adjusted one, and the couple still retain their marital intimacies.  When Lindon takes the security guard job, we know he means to do well.  But sometimes, life can test us in ways that we do not expect.

There is no bombast here, no overly dramatic episodes to make the director’s point.  Why?  Because life is like that.  We define ourselves and our value system by all the little decisions we make over time.  The final scene of the film is arresting and unforgettable because it shows how an average man, caught up in the moral ambiguity of life, can still chart his own course and display greatness of soul.  We know that Lindon will survive, despite all the setbacks he suffers, because he is a good man.  And the man of virtue, as Cicero tells us in Stoic Paradoxes, will never want for anything.

This movie, more than any other I have seen recently, embodies the Stoic ethic.  This is a Stoic film.


6 thoughts on “Sunday Movie Roundup (11/13/2016)

  1. I will check The Measure of a Man – your words make it out to be a wonderful movie.

    There’s a movie I watched this year which I think might interest you – it is called Bone Tomahawk.

    It’s a mediocre budgeted Western movie with superb acting of Kurt Russell, Patrick Wilson and Richard Jankins who portray a variety of stock Western themed characters and their merry-go band as they try to save the wife of Patrick Wilson’s character.

    What I loved about this movie is that it squeezed out all of the juice it had of its budget with superb dialogue between the characters.

    The most telling scene is the death of one character and what he tells the other who will survive. He accepts his death in a calm stoic manner, killing one more foe before he draws his last breath.

    Watching the movie made me think of Cicero’s On Duties.

    Love your Sunday Movie Roundup posts – you always write about movies I’d otherwise miss.

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I loved Midnight Run also, the acting throughout and action sequences were top notch. An understated classic. However DeNiro’s recent blowhard outbursts against Trump have put me off anything he does forever. I’m afraid his characters have infested his psyche. He seems to think he is still in Goodfellahs rather than just an old fart……

    Liked by 1 person

    • I think he’s just out of touch with what is going on in the country. Not only that, but he’s a wealthy celebrity who doesn’t understand the struggles and despair of the average guy these days.


      • Yes, same with Springsteen and Bon Jovi. They have this delusion they are working class heroes. Unfortunately for their very fragile egos they left their blue collar roots the second they made their first million. There’s no going back….. the hunger leaves pretty quick with the first major royalty cheque…..

        Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.